ISLANDS CHOICE Avon Park
ISLANDS CHOICE Logo

ISLANDS CHOICE

4.61026 reviews

Nestled in Avon Park, Islands Choice offers a taste of Jamaica right in your neighborhood. This restaurant specializes in authentic Caribbean dishes. The menu is diverse, featuring flavorful entrees and mouthwatering desserts. The laid-back atmosphere makes it a great spot for lunch or dinner.

The restaurant has lovely outdoor seating for those who enjoy fresh air while dining. Orders are available for takeout, perfect for enjoying at home. Friendly service and inviting decor create an enjoyable dining experience. The focus here is on quality ingredients and traditional recipes.

About

Islands Choice stands as a vibrant addition to the Avon Park food scene. It brings the essence of Caribbean cuisine to Florida. The owners, passionate about sharing their heritage, have transformed this local gem into a must-visit spot. Personal touches are evident in every detail, from the decor to the menu.

Here, each dish tells a story. The flavors reflect the Caribbean spirit, inviting guests to explore tastes that transport them away. This establishment thrives on community support, creating a warm atmosphere where everyone feels welcome. As locals gather and newcomers discover, the restaurant grows in popularity.

Get in Touch

1005 W Peel St, Avon Park, FL 33825, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday Closed
  • Tuesday 11:00-20:00
  • Wednesday 11:00-20:00
  • Thursday 11:00-20:00
  • Friday 11:00-20:00
  • Saturday 11:00-20:00
  • Sunday 11:00-16:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"We've tried several different plates, and all have been delicious. Our favorite one is the Brown Stew Chicken. If you're ever visiting or you live in Avon Park make sure to give them a try."

- Eddie B.

"Island Choice is a hidden gem in Avon Park! We recently had the jerk pork, rice, and mac & cheese. All food is always full of flavor and cooked to perfection. The jerk pork was especially tender with just the right amount of spice. The prices were very reasonable, and the portions were generous. The co owner, Ms. Wanda, is super friendly and gives that warm, welcoming island hospitality that makes the experience even better. Definitely recommend if you're craving authentic Caribbean food without leaving Avon Park."

- Tiff C.

"Looking for food. First choice was closed down. Found Islands Choice. Pleasantly surprised. So glad to run across. Jerk Pork so tender and flavorful. I'd be a customer for life if I lived around here. Dale"

- Dale K.

"Wow! Stopped by while I was in the area and I'm beyond impressed. Small shop, not any real room to eat in if there's multiple people there for pickup, but it's absolutely worth the visit. I got the jerk chicken with rice and plantains. The seasoning on the jerk chicken was perfect. Not too spicy and full of flavor. The rice was good but I don't know anyone who prioritizes that, I was more concerned with finishing the generous amount of chicken. ~edit I had to update this because it was so good I had to go back again. Right now I'm eating my cold leftovers from lunch straight from the fridge and it's still blowing my mind. I also got a couple beef patties this time around, they're flakey and delicious. So much flavor packed in this food."

- Chrissy N.

"The food was so good!! It's the kind of food where you close your eyes on the first bite because the flavor is so good! I was dancing with almost every bite. The service was great. And they have a beautifully decorated screened in porch area for eating. I definitely recommend you try it!"

- Tessa M.

"I was skeptical of tying this spot because I didn't see too many reviews and one review I saw said the food didn't take authentic, but I decided to try it anyway I love authentic Jamaican food And I've tried so many and was not impressed but this place is absolutely amazing. The owner did advise me that he is a new local business so that is why he doesn't have as many reviews I asked for sample. I tried it and I was in love! The food taste amazing taste so amazing. I'm so happy I decided to try it out! Did not disappoint But it is cash only or Zelle or cash app just a heads up"

- Destiney A.

"Super friendly people delicious food read the reviews. They were out of the jerk chicken that I wanted but got the brown stew chicken with the rice and the dumplings and it was so good portions are so big you leave here with over half a plate left."

- Jacob N.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visiting Islands Choice is a delightful experience. The authentic Jamaican cuisine is crafted with love. One standout dish is the Brown Stew Chicken, known for its tender meat and rich flavors. For seafood lovers, the Escovitch Fish is a must-try.

Apart from the food, the atmosphere adds another layer to the experience. A relaxed, cozy vibe invites visitors to linger over their meal. The friendly staff enhances the experience, offering warm island hospitality that keeps people coming back. Eating here feels like a true getaway without leaving Avon Park.

On busy weekends, it’s wise to arrive early for lunch or dinner. The restaurant tends to fill up quickly, especially on Saturdays. Alternatively, takeout is a great option if you're in a hurry. No matter how you choose to enjoy your meal, Islands Choice is worth a visit for its taste, ambiance, and community spirit.

Most Liked things

The food's authenticity shines through in every item on the menu. Diners rave about the generous portions and vibrant flavors. Desserts, particularly the Pound Cake, receive high praise. Guests appreciate the friendly service and welcoming atmosphere.

Many enjoy the outdoor seating, ideal for a lovely day. The accessibility features are also a plus, making it easy for everyone to enjoy delicious food at Islands Choice.

Most Disliked things

Some diners mention the limited indoor seating as a drawback. It can get crowded, especially during peak hours. A few reviews note that the wait time for food can be longer during busy times, but it's often worth it.

Cash payments, though common in small restaurants, catch some off guard since credit cards are not accepted. Checking ahead for peak times helps manage expectations regarding busyness and wait times.

FAQ

What are the must-try dishes at Islands Choice?

Try the Brown Stew Chicken and the Curried Goat. These dishes showcase authentic Jamaican flavors and offer a taste of the island's culinary heritage.

Is there outdoor seating available?

Yes! Islands Choice has a lovely terrace. It’s a great spot to enjoy delicious food while soaking up the sun.

What is the price range at Islands Choice?

Prices range from $10 to $20. This makes it an affordable choice for quality Jamaican dishes.

Do they offer vegetarian options?

Absolutely! Islands Choice caters to vegetarians with simple, traditional dishes. There’s something for everyone.

Is parking available at Islands Choice?

Yes, there is free parking available. It includes accessible parking spaces, making it convenient for all guests.